YAYYYYY IT’S TIME TO SEND MUSHY STUFF LIKE WE WERE TOLD TO THAT ONE TIME *rubs hands together* How would (separate) Papyrus, Napstablook and Mettaton react if their s/o sent them a heartfelt original poem about their love and other feelings for them via an old-fashioned, hand-written letter?~

underimagines:

Papyrus:

The moment the letter catches his eye, he bursts into the house screaming at Sans about how he’s received his first bit of fanmail. Finally, his fanbase is rearing it’s head!! He’s going to read this at once, for all to hear of his coolness!!

“Dear Papyrus--” Wowie, this handwriting looks familiar! He must know this Anonymous Fan. “Allow me to describe some complex feelings to you. Feelings like love, adoration, contentment, wholehearted dedication–”

Oh. Ohmygod. Sans do you know what this is. It’s a love letter!! He’s received an anonymous love letter!!! Ohmygod!! Ohmygod!!! It takes a little bit of hinting from Sans for Papyrus to finally put the dots together.

That adorable handwriting. The sweet scent, undeniably like that perfume you wear sometimes. The gentle, incredible way you word things, nearly identical to the way this letter is written!! You wrote him this letter!!! Ohmygod!!! A. A. A. A. A.

He’s torn between immediately confronting you about it, before he realizes. No!! This must be handled delicately!!! You are obviously trying to surpass him in Dating, & he has never been beaten–except maybe once before. For a gift like this, he must write you something in return!!!!

Ahem. “Dear Incredibly Anonymous Sender…”

Napstablook:

When they see the letter sitting on their desk, they think it might be a bill at first. They don’t get a lot of mail, since most of it goes to Mettaton, but…

They open it anyway. It smells nice, like flowers. Oh. They recognize your handwriting. Did you write this for them? That’s nice. Then they read it.

Oh. Oh no. This is so sweet. You really like them that much? You really think they’re cool? They’re not that great. They don’t think they deserve this much, but…it definitely makes them happy. It’s a very nice gift, thank you so much.

They set it down after a moment, unable to hide the tiny smile on their face. They don’t know what to do to make it up to you, but they’ll think of something. For now, they’re happy. 

They love you, a lot. & they’re happy you love them, too.

Mettaton:

When he sees it, he thinks it’s just another letter from one of his adorable fans. But then he opens it, & instantly the smell of roses overwhelm him. What’s more, he recognizes that handwriting. It’s yours.

He’s shocked. He doesn’t know how to react, as he reads the letter, letting it all soak in. The way you describe your love for him, like a poet to their muse, makes his circuits buzz & his SOUL tremble. Your words are carefully picked, dripping with all the drama & romance that he adores so much. You did all this for him. You love him this much.

He doesn’t even get to the end before he’s putting in an order for a private table at his fanciest establishment for you both that evening, following it up with a personal visit to your workplace to greet you–a specialty-made bouquet/chocolate order of all your favorites in hand. 

You spoiled him, now it’s his turn.